Why look beyond Ping Identity
Ping Identity is recognized for its comprehensive identity and access management (IAM) solutions, particularly within large enterprise and hybrid IT environments. Their product suite, including PingFederate, PingAccess, and PingDirectory, addresses complex requirements for workforce and customer identity. However, organizations may explore alternatives for several reasons. One common factor is the desire for a more cloud-native or SaaS-first approach, as some Ping Identity deployments can involve significant on-premises components and management overhead. While PingOne offers a cloud-based option, other vendors specialize in fully managed cloud IAM services from the outset.
Another consideration is pricing, as Ping Identity typically offers custom enterprise pricing models, which may not align with the budget structures of all organizations, particularly those with fluctuating user counts or a preference for transparent, tiered subscription models. The developer experience can also be a point of differentiation; while Ping Identity provides extensive documentation and SDKs for integration, some alternatives offer streamlined APIs and developer tools that cater to rapid application development and integration with modern microservices architectures. Furthermore, specific industry compliance needs or the desire for deeper integration with a particular vendor ecosystem (e.g., Microsoft Azure or AWS) might lead organizations to evaluate platforms designed for those environments.
Top alternatives ranked
-
1. Okta — Cloud-native identity for workforce and customers
Okta provides cloud-based identity and access management solutions for both workforce and customer use cases. Its platform includes capabilities such as single sign-on (SSO), multi-factor authentication (MFA), API access management, and universal directory services. Okta emphasizes ease of deployment and management through its SaaS model, making it a suitable option for organizations prioritizing cloud-first strategies and looking to reduce on-premises infrastructure. The platform offers a broad integration network with thousands of applications, simplifying user provisioning and deprovisioning across disparate systems. Okta's identity solutions are designed to support various compliance frameworks and provide granular access controls, catering to enterprises requiring robust security and governance. Developers can utilize Okta's APIs and SDKs to embed identity services into custom applications, enhancing user experience and security. Okta's approach often appeals to organizations seeking a more agile and scalable IAM solution compared to traditional on-premises deployments.
Best for: Organizations seeking a cloud-native, SaaS-first IAM solution with extensive application integrations and a focus on streamlined user experience for both workforce and customer identities.
Learn more: Okta profile | Okta official site
-
2. Microsoft Entra ID — Integrated identity for Microsoft ecosystems and hybrid environments
Microsoft Entra ID (formerly Azure Active Directory) is Microsoft's cloud-based identity and access management service, essential for organizations leveraging Microsoft 365, Azure, and other Microsoft cloud services. It provides core identity capabilities including single sign-on (SSO), multi-factor authentication (MFA), conditional access, identity protection, and device management. Entra ID is particularly strong for hybrid environments, enabling seamless synchronization of identities between on-premises Active Directory and the cloud. Its integration with Microsoft's broader security and productivity ecosystem offers a unified management experience. The platform supports a wide range of applications, both Microsoft and third-party, through its application gallery and custom application registration capabilities. For developers, Entra ID offers a comprehensive set of APIs (Microsoft Graph API) and SDKs for integrating identity into custom applications, enabling secure authentication and authorization. Its extensive feature set and deep integration within the Microsoft ecosystem make it a compelling choice for enterprises already invested in Microsoft technologies.
Best for: Enterprises deeply integrated into the Microsoft ecosystem, requiring robust identity management for hybrid cloud environments, and leveraging Microsoft 365 and Azure services.
Learn more: Microsoft Entra ID profile | Microsoft Entra ID product page
-
3. ForgeRock — Open-source core for adaptable identity solutions
ForgeRock offers a comprehensive digital identity platform built on an open-source core, providing flexibility for complex enterprise deployments. Its suite includes access management, identity management, directory services, and identity governance and administration (IGA). ForgeRock's architecture is designed for high scalability and customization, making it suitable for organizations with unique identity requirements or those needing to deploy identity services across hybrid and multi-cloud environments. The platform's open standards approach allows for deep integration with existing infrastructure and custom applications. ForgeRock emphasizes customer identity and access management (CIAM) capabilities, supporting large volumes of external users with features like self-service registration, progressive profiling, and consent management. Developers can leverage ForgeRock's APIs and SDKs to extend and integrate identity services, benefiting from the transparency and community support often associated with open-source technologies, while still relying on enterprise-grade features and support.
Best for: Large enterprises that require highly customizable, scalable identity solutions, prefer an open-source core for flexibility, and have complex CIAM or hybrid IT environment needs.
Learn more: ForgeRock profile | ForgeRock official website
-
4. ServiceNow — Integrated IT service and identity management
ServiceNow is primarily known as a cloud-based platform for IT service management (ITSM), IT operations management (ITOM), and IT business management (ITBM). However, its capabilities extend to identity and access management through integrations and its workflow automation engine. While not a standalone IAM vendor like Ping Identity or Okta, ServiceNow can manage user identities, access requests, and provisioning workflows, particularly within an IT context. It facilitates automated onboarding and offboarding processes, password resets, and access approvals by integrating with existing identity stores like Active Directory or LDAP. Organizations using ServiceNow for broader IT operations can consolidate identity-related tasks within a single platform, leveraging its robust workflow automation and reporting features. This approach is beneficial for streamlining IT processes where identity management is a component of a larger service delivery or operational workflow. Its strength lies in orchestrating identity-related tasks within a broader IT service catalog.
Best for: Enterprises already using ServiceNow for IT service management and operations, seeking to integrate and automate identity-related workflows within their existing ITSM framework.
Learn more: ServiceNow profile | ServiceNow documentation
-
5. Amazon Web Services (AWS) — Cloud-native identity for AWS environments
Amazon Web Services (AWS) provides a suite of identity services designed for cloud-native applications and infrastructure running within the AWS ecosystem. Key services include AWS Identity and Access Management (IAM) for managing access to AWS resources, Amazon Cognito for customer identity and access management (CIAM), and AWS Single Sign-On (AWS SSO) for workforce identity across AWS accounts and integrated applications. AWS IAM allows for fine-grained control over who can access which AWS services and resources, crucial for secure cloud deployments. Amazon Cognito offers user directories, authentication, and authorization for web and mobile applications, supporting millions of users. AWS SSO simplifies user access to multiple AWS accounts and third-party SaaS applications. These services are deeply integrated with the broader AWS platform, enabling developers to build secure and scalable applications without managing underlying identity infrastructure. For organizations heavily invested in AWS, these services provide a cohesive and highly scalable identity solution.
Best for: Organizations building and deploying applications primarily on AWS, requiring cloud-native identity solutions that integrate deeply with other AWS services for both workforce and customer identities.
Learn more: AWS profile | AWS documentation
-
6. IBM Security Verify — Hybrid cloud identity for enterprise security
IBM Security Verify offers a comprehensive suite of identity and access management (IAM) capabilities tailored for hybrid cloud environments. It includes features such as single sign-on (SSO), multi-factor authentication (MFA), identity analytics, and API security. The platform is designed to provide seamless and secure access for both workforce and customer identities across on-premises, cloud, and mobile applications. IBM Security Verify leverages AI-driven insights for risk-based authentication and adaptive access policies, enhancing security posture while improving user experience. Its architecture supports integration with a wide array of existing IT infrastructure and applications, making it suitable for large enterprises with complex, distributed environments. Developers can utilize its APIs to embed identity services into custom applications, enabling robust authentication and authorization mechanisms. IBM's emphasis on security intelligence and hybrid cloud flexibility positions Verify as a strong contender for organizations prioritizing enterprise-grade security and adaptable deployment models.
Best for: Large enterprises with complex hybrid cloud environments, requiring advanced security features like AI-driven adaptive access, and deep integration with existing IBM or diverse IT infrastructure.
Learn more: IBM Security Verify profile | IBM Security Verify documentation
-
7. Google Cloud Identity — Identity for Google Cloud and beyond
Google Cloud Identity is Google Cloud's Identity as a Service (IDaaS) solution, providing identity and access management for Google Workspace (formerly G Suite) and Google Cloud Platform (GCP). It offers capabilities such as single sign-on (SSO), multi-factor authentication (MFA), and user lifecycle management. Cloud Identity integrates seamlessly with Google's ecosystem, allowing organizations to manage user identities and access to Google applications and cloud resources from a centralized console. It also supports federation with existing identity providers like Active Directory, making it viable for hybrid environments. For developers, Google Cloud Identity provides APIs and SDKs to integrate identity services into custom applications, leveraging Google's global infrastructure for scalability and reliability. Its focus on ease of use and integration with Google's productivity and cloud services makes it an attractive option for organizations heavily invested in the Google ecosystem or those seeking a straightforward, cloud-native identity solution with strong security features.
Best for: Organizations heavily invested in Google Workspace and Google Cloud Platform, seeking a cloud-native identity solution with seamless integration across Google's services and robust security.
Learn more: Google Cloud Identity profile | Google Cloud Identity overview
Side-by-side
| Feature/Provider | Ping Identity | Okta | Microsoft Entra ID | ForgeRock | ServiceNow (IAM context) | AWS Identity Services | IBM Security Verify | Google Cloud Identity |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Deployment Model | Hybrid/On-prem/Cloud | SaaS (Cloud-native) | Cloud/Hybrid | Hybrid/On-prem/Cloud | SaaS (Cloud) | Cloud-native | Hybrid Cloud | Cloud-native |
| Core Focus | Enterprise IAM (Workforce/CIAM) | Workforce & CIAM | Microsoft Ecosystem Identity | Enterprise & CIAM (Open-source core) | ITSM & Workflow Automation | AWS Resource & App Identity | Hybrid Cloud Enterprise Security | Google Ecosystem Identity |
| Single Sign-On (SSO) | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Via integrations | AWS SSO | Yes | Yes |
| Multi-Factor Auth (MFA) | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Via integrations | Via IAM/Cognito | Yes | Yes |
| Directory Services | PingDirectory | Universal Directory | Entra ID Directory | ForgeRock Directory Services | User tables/Integrations | Cognito User Pools | Yes | Cloud Identity Directory |
| API Access Management | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Limited (workflow APIs) | Via API Gateway/IAM | Yes | Yes |
| Developer Experience | Extensive SDKs/APIs | Strong SDKs/APIs | Microsoft Graph API | Open-source APIs/SDKs | Flow Designer/APIs | AWS SDKs/APIs | APIs/SDKs | Google Cloud SDKs/APIs |
| Pricing Model | Custom Enterprise | Tiered/Custom | Subscription/Tiered | Custom Enterprise | Subscription/Tiered | Pay-as-you-go | Custom Enterprise | Subscription/Tiered |
How to pick
Selecting an identity and access management (IAM) solution requires evaluating your organization's specific needs, existing infrastructure, and long-term strategy. Consider the following factors:
-
Deployment Model Preference: Do you need a purely cloud-native solution, or do you have significant on-premises resources that require hybrid identity management? For a cloud-first approach with minimal on-premises infrastructure, Okta or Google Cloud Identity might be suitable. If your environment is heavily hybrid, with a mix of on-premises applications and cloud services, Microsoft Entra ID or IBM Security Verify offer robust solutions for bridging these environments, often with strong synchronization capabilities to existing directories like Active Directory. ForgeRock also excels in hybrid deployments, particularly where extensive customization is required.
-
Ecosystem Integration: Evaluate your current technology stack. If your organization is deeply invested in Microsoft 365 and Azure, Microsoft Entra ID offers the most seamless and integrated experience. Similarly, for organizations building primarily on AWS, native AWS identity services like IAM and Cognito provide deep integration with other AWS resources and a pay-as-you-go pricing model. Google Cloud Identity is the natural choice for Google Workspace and Google Cloud Platform users. Choosing a solution that aligns with your primary cloud provider can simplify management and reduce integration overhead.
-
Complexity of Identity Requirements: Assess the sophistication of your identity needs. If you require advanced features such as risk-based authentication, adaptive access policies, or complex identity governance and administration (IGA), vendors like IBM Security Verify or ForgeRock offer comprehensive capabilities. For simpler, more standardized workforce or customer identity needs, Okta or Microsoft Entra ID may provide a more straightforward implementation path. ServiceNow, while not a core IAM provider, can be highly effective if your primary goal is to integrate identity-related tasks into broader IT service management workflows.
-
Developer Experience and Customization: Consider the importance of developer tools, APIs, and SDKs for integrating identity into custom applications. All listed alternatives offer developer resources, but the ease of use and the depth of customization vary. ForgeRock, with its open-source core, provides significant flexibility for developers who need to tailor the identity platform extensively. Okta and Microsoft Entra ID offer well-documented APIs and SDKs that support modern application development. For organizations with specific requirements for embedding identity directly into their applications, evaluating the developer documentation and available SDKs for languages relevant to your team is crucial.
-
Pricing and Scalability: Understand the pricing models and how they align with your budget and expected growth. SaaS providers like Okta, Microsoft Entra ID, and Google Cloud Identity often have tiered subscription models that scale with user count. AWS identity services follow a pay-as-you-go model, which can be cost-effective for variable usage. For large enterprises with stable, high user counts, custom enterprise pricing from vendors like ForgeRock or IBM Security Verify might be more appropriate. Consider not just the per-user cost but also the operational overhead and potential for future expansion.
-
Industry-Specific Compliance: If your organization operates in a highly regulated industry (e.g., healthcare, finance), ensure the chosen alternative supports the necessary compliance certifications (e.g., HIPAA, GDPR, SOC 2). Most enterprise-grade IAM solutions address common compliance needs, but verifying specific attestations and features for your industry is essential for regulatory adherence. For instance, Ping Identity is known for its strong compliance framework, and similar due diligence should be applied to any alternative.