Why look beyond Commvault

Commvault is a data management platform designed for enterprise data backup, recovery, and hybrid cloud data protection, offering features like ransomware protection and compliance tools. Organizations may seek alternatives to Commvault for several reasons. Some might require a solution with a different pricing model, as Commvault primarily offers custom enterprise pricing, which may not align with budget structures or procurement processes of all companies. Others might be looking for more streamlined user interfaces or simplified deployment options, particularly for environments that prioritize ease of use over extensive customization capabilities. Specific integrations with niche or emerging cloud platforms might also lead businesses to explore other vendors, as the breadth of native integrations can vary between data protection providers. Furthermore, companies with specific recovery time objectives (RTOs) or recovery point objectives (RPOs) might evaluate alternatives that offer different architectural approaches or guarantees for their critical workloads. Finally, organizations with existing infrastructure investments might seek solutions that offer deeper integration with their current technology stack, such as specific hypervisors, storage arrays, or public cloud services, to optimize performance and reduce operational complexity.

Top alternatives ranked

  1. 1. Veeam — Data backup, recovery, and management for virtual, physical, and cloud environments

    Veeam offers data protection solutions that span virtual, physical, and cloud-native workloads, focusing on backup, recovery, and data management. It provides capabilities such as continuous data protection, instant recovery for virtual machines, and ransomware detection. Veeam's platform is designed to integrate with various hypervisors, storage systems, and cloud providers, aiming to offer flexibility for hybrid IT environments. The company emphasizes a unified platform for data security, recovery, and monitoring across different data types and locations. Veeam has expanded its offerings to include backup for SaaS applications and Kubernetes environments, addressing modern data protection challenges. Its licensing models often involve a per-workload or per-socket approach, which can be a consideration for cost management.

    Best for: Organizations prioritizing fast recovery times for virtualized environments and hybrid cloud data protection.

  2. 2. Rubrik — Cloud data management and enterprise data protection

    Rubrik provides a data security platform that integrates backup, disaster recovery, archival, and data governance into a single interface. Its architecture is designed for simplicity and scalability, particularly for hybrid and multi-cloud environments. Rubrik emphasizes ransomware recovery capabilities, including immutable backups and automated recovery workflows. The platform offers policy-driven automation for data protection tasks, aiming to reduce manual overhead. Rubrik also provides data intelligence features for compliance, e-discovery, and vulnerability management. The company's approach focuses on a software-defined, API-driven platform that supports various applications, databases, and cloud services. Rubrik's pricing typically follows a subscription model based on capacity or number of workloads.

    Best for: Enterprises seeking a modern, cloud-native approach to data security and rapid ransomware recovery.

  3. 3. Cohesity — Hyperscale data consolidation and protection

    Cohesity offers a data management platform designed to consolidate secondary data and applications, including backups, archives, file shares, and object storage, onto a single web-scale platform. Its architecture aims to simplify data protection and management across on-premises, cloud, and edge environments. Cohesity focuses on reducing data silos, improving operational efficiency, and enhancing data security, particularly against ransomware threats. The platform provides features for instant recovery, data immutability, and integration with various public clouds. Cohesity also offers data insights and governance capabilities, allowing organizations to derive value from their secondary data. The company's solutions are built on a distributed file system, offering scalability and resilience. Pricing models usually involve a subscription based on capacity or data managed.

    Best for: Organizations looking to consolidate secondary data and simplify data management across diverse environments.

  4. 4. ServiceNow — Enterprise IT service management and workflow automation

    ServiceNow offers a cloud-based platform for digital workflows, extending beyond traditional IT service management (ITSM) to include IT operations management (ITOM), IT business management (ITBM), and security operations. While not a direct data backup solution like Commvault, ServiceNow's capabilities in IT asset management and configuration management databases (CMDB) are relevant in a broader data protection strategy. Its platform can automate incident response, change management, and disaster recovery processes, ensuring that data protection workflows are integrated into overall IT operations. ServiceNow's strength lies in its ability to connect disparate systems and automate complex enterprise workflows, which can indirectly support data protection by streamlining the management of infrastructure that hosts critical data. The platform's extensibility allows for custom application development to address specific operational requirements.

    Best for: Large enterprises seeking to integrate data protection workflows into broader IT service management and operations automation.

  5. 5. SAP S/4HANA — Real-time enterprise resource planning

    SAP S/4HANA is an enterprise resource planning (ERP) suite designed for large enterprises, running on the SAP HANA in-memory database. It integrates core business processes such as finance, manufacturing, supply chain, sales, and human resources. While SAP S/4HANA is not a data protection product in the same category as Commvault, its role in managing an organization's critical business data makes its own data protection and recovery mechanisms crucial. Organizations using S/4HANA rely on robust backup and recovery strategies for the underlying database and application infrastructure. SAP provides tools and recommendations for backing up HANA databases and ensuring business continuity. The decision to use S/4HANA influences the type of data protection required for the ERP system itself, often necessitating solutions that offer application-aware backups and rapid recovery for complex, integrated systems.

    Best for: Large enterprises requiring a comprehensive ERP system where the data protection strategy must align with critical business process continuity.

  6. 6. Amazon Web Services — Comprehensive suite of cloud computing services

    Amazon Web Services (AWS) offers a broad range of cloud computing services, including infrastructure, platform, and packaged software offerings. For data protection, AWS provides services like AWS Backup for centralizing backup management across AWS services, on-premises data, and hybrid environments. Other relevant services include Amazon S3 for durable object storage, Amazon Glacier for archival, and AWS Elastic Disaster Recovery for rapid recovery of on-premises and cloud-based applications. While not a single, integrated data protection appliance like Commvault, AWS provides the building blocks for creating highly customized, scalable, and cost-effective data protection solutions within the cloud. Organizations leveraging AWS can design their backup and disaster recovery strategies using these native services, often integrating them with third-party tools for enhanced capabilities or specific compliance requirements.

    Best for: Organizations heavily invested in AWS infrastructure seeking to leverage native cloud services for scalable and flexible data protection.

Side-by-side

Feature Commvault Veeam Rubrik Cohesity ServiceNow SAP S/4HANA Amazon Web Services
Core Function Enterprise Data Protection Backup & Recovery Cloud Data Security Hyperscale Data Consolidation Digital Workflow Automation ERP Suite Cloud Computing Services
Deployment Model On-prem, Hybrid, SaaS On-prem, Hybrid, Cloud Hybrid Cloud, SaaS On-prem, Cloud, Edge SaaS (Cloud) On-prem, Cloud Cloud (IaaS, PaaS, SaaS)
Primary Use Case Enterprise backup, DR, compliance VM backup, DR, data management Ransomware recovery, data governance Secondary data consolidation ITSM, ITOM, business workflows Core business process management Cloud infrastructure, scalable solutions
Ransomware Protection Yes (e.g., Metallic ThreatWise) Yes (e.g., immutable backups) Yes (e.g., immutability, recovery) Yes (e.g., immutability, detection) Indirect (workflow automation) Indirect (database security) Yes (via S3 immutability, AWS Backup)
Hybrid Cloud Support Extensive Extensive Extensive Extensive Integrates with cloud services Supports cloud deployments Native cloud platform
API Availability Comprehensive REST APIs Extensive APIs for integration API-driven platform RESTful APIs Robust APIs for integration APIs for integration Extensive APIs for all services
Target Audience Large Enterprises SMB to Enterprise Mid-market to Enterprise Mid-market to Enterprise Large Enterprises Large Enterprises All scales (developers to enterprises)

How to pick

Selecting an alternative to Commvault involves evaluating an organization's specific data protection needs, existing infrastructure, and strategic objectives. The decision-making process can be structured around several key considerations:

1. Define your primary data protection goals:

  • If your priority is rapid recovery of virtualized environments and hybrid cloud data: Solutions like Veeam excel in this area, offering features like instant VM recovery and broad hypervisor support.
  • If ransomware recovery and data security are paramount: Platforms such as Rubrik and Cohesity focus on immutable backups, automated recovery, and proactive threat detection.
  • If you need to consolidate secondary data and simplify data management: Cohesity is designed for hyperscale data consolidation across various data types.

2. Assess your current IT environment and future roadmap:

  • For heavily virtualized environments (VMware, Hyper-V): Veeam's origins and strengths are deeply rooted in virtual machine protection.
  • For organizations with significant cloud adoption (especially AWS): Amazon Web Services provides native services that can be leveraged to build highly integrated cloud-native data protection strategies.
  • For hybrid environments with a mix of on-premises, cloud, and edge data: Rubrik, Cohesity, and Veeam offer comprehensive support for diverse infrastructures.
  • If your strategy involves extensive workflow automation and IT service management: ServiceNow can integrate data protection processes into broader operational workflows, though it is not a direct backup solution.

3. Consider the scale and complexity of your data:

  • For large enterprises with vast and complex data sets: Solutions like Rubrik and Cohesity are built for scalability and managing petabytes of data across distributed environments.
  • For specific application data protection (e.g., SAP S/4HANA): The data protection strategy must align with the application's requirements, often involving application-aware backups and recovery. While SAP S/4HANA itself is an ERP system, its data protection relies on underlying infrastructure and specialized backup tools.

4. Evaluate pricing models and total cost of ownership (TCO):

  • Compare licensing structures (per-capacity, per-workload, subscription) and consider hidden costs such as storage, networking, and professional services.
  • Request detailed quotes from multiple vendors based on your specific requirements to understand the TCO over several years.

5. Review compliance, security, and governance requirements:

  • Ensure the alternative meets industry-specific compliance standards (e.g., HIPAA, GDPR, SOC 2).
  • Verify security features like encryption, immutability, and access controls align with your organization's policies.

By systematically evaluating these factors, organizations can identify a Commvault alternative that best fits their technical needs, operational preferences, and budgetary constraints.